After two decades of advising university professors across Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and New York, we’ve noticed a critical gap in retirement planning that deserves deeper examination. While most academic professionals are familiar with their 403(b) plans, the powerful combination of 403(b) and 457(b) plans often remains unexplored, particularly in how these vehicles can work in concert to create more favorable retirement outcomes.
The Unique Position of Academic Retirement Planning
University professionals occupy a distinct position in the retirement planning landscape. Unlike professionals in most other sectors, academics may have access to both 403(b) and 457(b) plans simultaneously. This dual availability isn't merely a convenience—it represents a sophisticated opportunity for tax-advantaged retirement savings that can significantly alter retirement trajectories.
Understanding the 403(b) Foundation
The 403(b) plan has long served as the cornerstone of academic retirement planning, but its full potential often remains unrealized. While the basic annual contribution limit of $23,500 (for 2025)1 is widely known, the plan offers nuanced advantages specifically designed for academic careers. For instance, the 15-year service catch-up provision can allow additional contributions of up to $3,000 annually2—a feature that acknowledges the unique long-term commitment of academic careers.
The investment landscape within 403(b) plans deserves particular attention. While traditional options often include a range of annuity products, many modern plans have evolved to offer diverse investment vehicles, including mutual funds and target-date options. This evolution provides opportunities for more sophisticated investment strategies, though it also requires careful consideration of how these options align with your broader financial objectives.
The Strategic Role of 457(b) Plans
The 457(b) plan, while less commonly understood, offers distinct advantages that can significantly enhance academic retirement planning. Perhaps its most notable feature is the absence of early withdrawal penalties (before age 60) —a characteristic that provides valuable flexibility in retirement planning. This becomes particularly relevant when considering phased retirement or early retirement scenarios, which are increasingly common in academic careers.
What makes the 457(b) particularly powerful is that457(b) contributions do not reduce the contributions one can make to another employer sponsored retirement plan. When combined with an available and eligible 403(b) plan, this effectively doubles your tax-advantaged retirement savings capacity. Individuals in this scenario can contribute up to $23,500 to both their 457(b) and 403(b) plans in 2025.3
Factors to Consider
The real sophistication in academic retirement planning lies not in understanding each plan individually, but in developing an integrated strategy that leverages both plans' unique characteristics. This integration should consider several factors:
The timing of contributions can be strategically planned across both accounts, taking into account your current tax situation and expected future income patterns. For instance, during high-income years—perhaps when consulting or research grants supplement your base salary—maximizing contributions to both plans can provide significant tax advantages.
Investment allocation across both plans should be viewed as part of a single, comprehensive strategy. This might mean using different investment options available in each plan to create a more diversified portfolio, or strategically placing certain types of investments in one plan versus the other based on tax considerations and distribution plans.
Distribution strategies become particularly important as you approach retirement. The flexibility of the 457(b) plan can be especially valuable in early retirement scenarios, while the traditional structure of the 403(b) might be better suited for long-term distributions during full retirement.
A Practical Example
Consider the case of a tenured professor approaching retirement. By utilizing both plans, they might structure their retirement savings in the following way: The 403(b) could serve as the primary long-term retirement vehicle, invested in a mix of equity and fixed-income options, while the 457(b) might be positioned more conservatively to provide flexibility for early retirement or phased retirement income. This dual approach can provide flexibility and confidence—a combination particularly valuable in academic careers where retirement transitions often occur gradually.*
Your Personalized Strategy
While larger financial institutions offer standardized approaches to retirement planning, the complexity of academic careers demands a more nuanced strategy. Your retirement planning should be as thoughtful and individualized as your research methodology. Understanding the technical aspects of 403(b) and 457(b) plans is just the beginning—the real value comes from crafting a strategy with a goal to align your specific academic journey, career transitions, and long-term aspirations.
We welcome the opportunity to have a focused conversation about your retirement planning needs. Unlike institutional approaches that can miss the subtleties of academic careers, our discussion will center on understanding your unique situation—whether you're navigating tenure, managing research grants, or planning for phased retirement. Let's explore what options may enhance your retirement strategy in a way that is sometimes overlooked. Schedule a personal consultation to discuss how we can help manage your academic benefits and create a strategy aligned with your goals.
Disclosure: Content in this material is for general information only and not intended to provide specific advice or recommendations for any individual. Investing involves risks including possible loss of principal. Investment advice offered through Stratos Wealth Advisors, LLC, a registered investment advisor. Stratos Wealth Advisors, LLC and Emeritus Wealth Partners are separate entities.
1 Fidelity Smart Money: 403(b) contribution limits for 2023, 2024, and 2025
2 IRS Issue Snapshot - 403(b) plans - Catch-up contributions
3 CS Understanding 457(b) vs. 403(b) Retirement Plans
.svg)
.svg)
